I came back from Nice on Saturday(17TH) at noon in a fantastic mood, feeling somehow regenerated after having met Mephistopheles in person in La Damnation de Faust by the beloved Hector Berlioz.
Direction Musicale : Philippe Auguin
Mise en espace : Yves Coudray
Lumières : Bernard Barbero
Faust : Sergeï Semiskur
Marguerite: Oksana Volkova
Méphistophélès : Samuel Ramey
Brander : Jean-Marie Frémeau
Orchestre Philharmonique de Nice
Chœur de l’Opéra de Nice
Samuel Ramey, this fantastic bass is almost my twin brother and looking at his smart appearance, his piercing and shining eyesight, sharing and feeling his tremendous passion for this role, I felt young again. On Friday night, in 'La Damnation de Faust'he gave us the proof of his eternal youth! In a recent interview in 2010 he said:
"Singers can't really hear themselves that well," "A singer's voice is just like an automobile: You have to have somebody take it in for a 20,000-mile checkup.(...)
"My teacher, when I see him now, we just try to work on things to try to keep the voice from sounding the age that it is," Ramey says. "I just try to bring out what's left of the youth in the voice."
Indeed on friday night(16th), he demonstrated that there is a lot of youth left in his voice. His passion for this music and this role gave energy to the whole cast as soon as he stepped on stage. He sounded terrific with a complete mastering of a role he has been performing for twenty years at least. What a treat!I like this tale, the eight stories and the music in any case, but with him, it was like "paradise' even in hell!
Young Charles Castronovo was Faust, and was not expected so that was a nice surprise too! ( he was replacing Sergeï Semiskur, he must have been informed at short notice, he was following the scores in this semi-staged performance).
I was thrilled again by his subtle rendition and enjoyed the first act, the renewal of nature with the peasants' dances, which will never be shared by him, because he is depressed by all his knowledge and is incapable of sheer happiness. CH.Castronovo was very cautious with all the high pitched notes, and negociated some very fine ones. He was quite loud over the thumping orchestral waves and chorus, he made a real achievement on top of the rocking orchestra, very convincing too. The Russian mezzo, Oksana Volkova, was also at ease vocally, with a wide vocal range and perfect French sounds. Her very slim figure was well matched with the 'neat and tidy' looks of Faust- charles Castronovo. I ravished at her 'Roi de Thulé' (always a hit), and the cello was brilliant too. Brander was good, but very conventional and oldish. (He was Don Gormès in le Cid, with whiter hair than Don Diègue). I would have prefered some one like Eric Martin Bonnet who managed to be witty, having some very personal way of making us actually see this poor rat run along his arms...before being roasted!
The whole story was well lit-up with contrastive reds and blues, it had few moves to the side boxes, one figuring Marguerite's bedroom the other one for the master of ceremony to command the various journeys until the last one for Faust, and the chorus also made some moves on request of Mephostopheles's gestures. It was not at all static and could be followed like eight tales in action. The only furniture were two armchairs on both sides, the Royal looking one for
both Faust in his study and then for Mephisto, the smaller one for Marguerite's dream. A swirl of passion rocked the house! As for Samuel Ramey's voice, even if it slightly wobbled at times, it kept an immense resounding effect and a deep command of the acting. He simply loved it and made his young fellow singers join his passion. He boosted Castronovo when he appeared in part II. Then it gave to this Berlioz piece (which had been a flop at its creation in Paris, 6 December 1846), the jubilant touch it deserves. He simply was grand! I was so happy to be in the audience for Berlioz's Damnation. I always try to attend a Berlioz production, I think I understand and love his music more and more. Of course it is always fascinating to follow a live 'Ride to hell' here both Faust and Mephistopheles were holding to their score-stands (with no scores for Samuel Ramey of course!) pretending to ride their black horses. Faust's singing part is huge, his ode to Nature is a momentum "'Nature immense, impénétrable et fière". Charles Castronovo was convincing and impressive in this colossal part.
My last Damnation was at Marseilles Opera House with a daring Marguerite, Anna Caterina Antonacci, and the same conductor LINK . This time, the four voices were top class and they were all acting this pseudo opera which does not really need to be staged. The orchestra and chorus are part of the imagery: it is all depicted in the music. Each time, I enjoy the sarcastic parts like the"Amen", 'Voici des roses", and "petite Louison ( I have memories of 'Bonne nuit...AH!' sung to me when I was a child!)"the Flea" or the"Rat' tunes! That friday night Samuel Ramey was magnificient in all his hits and the audience was under the spell! Marguerite and Faust have true lyrical romances to sing and they were also very moving, adding the delicate touch to this fairy tale which ends like a nightmare. Being both young and attractive, their meeting was even more credible! The awesome Devil was the center of this performance and I was moved to applaude Samuel Ramey on this provincial stage... forty years of loyal services to this Art form... with all my respect to such a beautiful artist and person, and to Berlioz!
I do hope to see some young singers tackle this Mephistopheles's role in the style Samuel Ramey has been doing it.
I left my friends after an admirative converstion about the artists and Samuel Ramey. They went back stage to greet him (I did not, sticking to my old habit of waiting for the artists at the stagedoor, they did not appear,they had a party after the show, very well deserved!).
It was a very warm night, and I stopped for another drink under the pepper trees, thinking it was such a treat to have seen this performance in Nice, where I was born, where my parents learnt the art of singing too...where my two grandparents families settled so many years ago, and where dear Berlioz stayed to recover and write some music in the Tower of Nice Castle, with a stupendous view on the bay....
Bonne Nuit! LINK- Samuel Ramey "A date with the

Devil"
What a fabulous account, Yvette - I could just imagine myself there by the way you describe things. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThere is another La Damnation de Faust on BBC radio 3 next Thursday at 14.00 uk time ... if you fancy another dose of the devil!!
Another date with the Devil! Yes! Thanks... but I must share the VK one, one day now I am aware of its existence... Have a good day! ...Sunshine?
ReplyDeleteSunshine :)
ReplyDeletethanks Yvette, for the wonderful review! I really love this opera since the first time i was introduced to it in 1999. I never knew the story though, until today when i finally got around to see a fully staged one with english subtitle on YT:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66390CABDBE6EC1E
I'll check out Samuel Ramey, a new name for me.
I heard Charles Castronovo twice and really love his voice and emotion. The one i was most touched was the scene at LA opera where he sang about love and passion while his character was being shot in a revolution (il postino), drew tears to quite a few of us.
hopefully the one with kasarova will come soon as well... i still don't have it...
Dear Thadieu, thanks for getting an interest here! I could have made more efforts to characterize the arias of each protagonist so it is not accurate with only my impressions really. Yes, Berlioz is a fascinating musician and human character. As he wrote a lot himself about his life and the music being performed around him, as a critic, it is really worth reading him as well! As for La Damnation, it is a wonderful piece, challenging the imagination, and served by an artist like Samuel Ramey makes it even more attractive.I also had the chance to see Il Postino and I simply loved what Charles Castronovo made out of this role! But the French critic did not like the music and the libretto, it was too simple for them... not for me!He was brilliant vocally and very moving dramatically according to me... sometimes you have to be not so much on the 'intellectual' side to respond to works of Art....
ReplyDeleteThanks for this link it's great and easy to follow the opera! I am ordering the Damnation with Vesselina. This is a fantastic group Smorgy united around Vesselina! Have a nice day!
Hello Yvette,
ReplyDeleteThis Friday night I was there too; I had travelled 900 km from Paris to meet my idol again after having met him in Berlin for the first time in June. In Nice I had the most wonderful lyric week-end in my life! On Friday night I was on the third row & on Sunday I was on the FIRST row. Charles Castronovo's presence was a delightful surprise & I enjoyed very much Volkova's and Frémeau's singing (Oksana, though she does not speak French at all, has indeed a very good diction in French!). You are right about the party after the show; I had the wonderful chance to get there for just a few minutes, so I met Charles, Oksana &, of course, the Devil himself, who is the kindest man on Earth... Mamma mia, what a night! For Berlioz, for the conductor (fantastic Auguin, brimming with energy), for the choir &orchestra (we know how important they are there), & of course for the soloists. On Saturday there was a very interesting conference about this masterpiece, which I attended, of course, in the presence of all the artists; and on Sunday I met all of them again. I thought I was dreaming when Mr Ramey waved to me at the end of the Sunday performance... & I thought I was in Heaven (or in Hell, considering the guy) when I had a chat with Charles & Sam, just the three of us, on Sunday afternoon; & imagine how I felt during my little walk (500 meters), alone together with Sam Ramey!...
I am sorry Camille but I have just discovered your post which was in the Spam... I am glad to read how much you enjoyed this rendition! and of course you were very lucky to meet the Devil himself! He is such a great person!
DeleteHello Yvette,
DeleteThank you for your answer! Ooooh yes I feel lucky & he is a great person! I just hope that Sam will come back to Europe before he retires. I shall never forget our encounter... nor his kisses! E-mail & Facebook (to which I surrendered a few months ago & on which I only write about music) are good tools to keep in touch with him but nothing replaces the real thing...
I'm delighted to hear that Ramey sounded so good! He will be 70 this year, and as far as I'm concerned, he can go on singing forever!
ReplyDelete